When I first came across BrewDog, it felt like something genuinely different.
I hadn’t really followed their early rise.
It was around 2012 or 2013 when they properly entered my world — around the time of the Diageo awards controversy — just as I was starting to take more of an interest in beer beyond simply drinking it.
And then I found the BrewDog bar in Leeds, just by the Corn Exchange.
Punk IPA was a revelation.
Floral, hoppy, bold — it stood apart from everything else I’d had at the time. It wasn’t just another pint. It felt like a shift in what beer could be.
And the bar itself reinforced that feeling.
Industrial design. Retro games. Board games. A space that felt deliberately different from the traditional pub — yet still part of a wider routine. We’d often end up there alongside places like Whitelock’s, moving between old and new without really thinking about it.
At that point, BrewDog worked.
The “Punk” Idea
BrewDog built its identity around being “punk.”
Anti-establishment. Rule-breaking. Not like the big brewers.
And early on, that idea held weight — because the product backed it up.
But even then, there was a tension.
Initiatives like Equity for Punks always felt slightly uneasy to me. There’s something inherently contradictory about positioning yourself as anti-establishment while actively trying to become the next major player.
“Punk” works brilliantly as a marketing idea.
But it’s much harder to sustain as a business model.
Because the moment you succeed…
you risk becoming the very thing you were pushing against.
Expansion — and Something Shifts
I spent much of 2014 to 2020 overseas.
And in that time, BrewDog expanded rapidly.
More bars. More products. More visibility.
But when I came back, something felt different.
Punk IPA didn’t quite taste the same.
That distinctive floral edge felt thinner — less defined.
And perhaps more noticeably, it was everywhere.
Supermarkets. Chain pubs. Wetherspoons.
In some cases, it was even cheaper in Wetherspoons than in BrewDog’s own bars — which raises an interesting question about positioning, identity, and scale.
If something starts as “different,”
what happens when it becomes the default?
From Movement to Chain
The bars shifted too.
The original Leeds site closed.
The replacement felt less central, less natural.
Other locations came and went — Bradford, Huddersfield — some disappearing before I’d even had a chance to visit.
And gradually, the experience changed.
Not necessarily worse — but different.
Less like a movement.
More like a chain.
And that’s not inherently a criticism. Plenty of chains do a perfectly good job.
But it does represent a shift away from what BrewDog originally felt like.
Culture, Controversy, and Expectation
I wasn’t closely following the various controversies as they unfolded.
But I think there’s a broader point worth making here.
When a brand builds itself on being different — on being better — expectations change.
People don’t just judge the product.
They judge the behaviour.
And that’s where the idea of “punk” becomes more complicated.
Because it’s one thing to position yourself as rebellious.
It’s another to maintain that position once you’re operating at scale.
At some point, the line between disruption and standard business practice becomes harder to see.
A Wider Craft Beer Question
BrewDog’s influence goes far beyond its own bars.
It helped shape the modern craft beer model:
- Keg-forward
- Branding-led
- Premium pricing
The idea that you can create a new product, package it well, and sell it at a higher price point has become the norm.
And countless breweries have followed that path.
But that raises a bigger question.
If everyone is doing it…
is it still different?
So — Is BrewDog Still Punk?
I don’t think BrewDog disappears.
It’s too established for that.
But it does feel like it’s entered a different phase.
Less of a disruptor.
More of a recognised name.
Less of a movement.
More of a business.
And maybe that’s inevitable.
Because the real question isn’t just about BrewDog.
It’s about any brand that defines itself as anti-establishment.
Can you still be “punk”…
once you’ve made it?
Watch the Video
Join the Conversation
I’d be genuinely interested in where people land on this.
Is BrewDog still “punk”?
Or has it simply become part of the establishment it once challenged?
Comments
Post a Comment